Thursday, 15 February 2018

Punjab National Bank Fraud: An in depth analysis of a common men

A large chunk of mass Indian including media persons are making storm on their cup of tea regarding Punjab National Bank  mega fraud for Rs 11880 crores where Mr Nirav Modi the Numero Uno suspect who alleged siphoning this fund from Bank out of country. Common men are as usual divided into two and slinging mud to either of political parties   BJP or INC. Some are even speaking in terms of NPA the word is now known to almost every Indian without knowing the meaning of the word in absolute term. I will try to explain the meaning of NPA for common people as well as I will explain how this fraud slowly took shape into a mammoth scam in history of Indian economy. Let us discuss first
What is NPA is absolute Banking term?
When an advance becomes overdue either by installment due or and interest thereon or both more than 29 days it is called “Temporarily Irregular Account” This not defined as NPA
Where an advance (Rs25.00 Lakhs and above) become overdue either by installment due or and interest thereon or both more than 59 days it is termed as SMA (special mention account)
When an advance becomes overdue either by installment due or and interest thereon or both more than 89 days it is called NPA account
This is discussed in broader sense only for consumption of general public, without going deep inside where many more modalities are there.
Now an advance may be different types, Viz, Working Capital for running expenses for a unit, term loan for purchase of machineries and equipment for business and third one in bank guarantee. Since this mega fraud in PNB was against Bank Guarantee, we with discuss on this only.
Bank Guarantee is of two types viz, Performance Guarantee and Deferred Payment Guarantee. Now Deferred Payment Guarantee is given by Bank against large amount Equipment finance to the manufacturer instead of direct Term Loan. Performance Guarantee is issued against import license of parties where good are delivered against the Bank guarantee. This is issued as a letter of undertaking (LOU) given by Bank on behalf of importer to the exporter at other foreign land. Bank Guarantee was extended time to time to the party by Bank authorities wherein as per banking rule party had to deposit 100% cash collateral securities against issuance of each Bank Guarantee or extension thereof. After the transaction is over, this has to be invariably loaded in the Core Banking System by a maker and will be approved by a checker. Thus the amount of Guarantee will reflect in the System with absolute transparency amount will be added to Bank’s total exposure under the head of Contingent Liability.
In this very case, one fraudulent Deputy Manager in a particular branch has taken chance of the loophole of the system. He issued the Performance Guarantee as Letter of Undertaking manually, and handed over the document to the party without obtaining any cash collateral against this. He has sent the information through SWIFT mode (for international remittances of fund) by using his own password. This he continued from 2008 to till his retirement from the service, i.e. about a year back.
So, this is clearly a fault of that very branch and PNB authorities. He was not transferred from this branch for many years and that is unusual. His desk was not changed also due to reasons best known to his authorities.
So, it is clear case of laxity in PNB and this is their in house problem. The account  has  nowhere the account became NPA. Neither authorities of RBI have any connection with this fraud nor is involvement of any political party established. Common men are requested to refrain making any loose comments against RBI or involvement of any political party.